Skip to content
← All resources

How to Audit Your Small Business Website in 15 Minutes (Free Checklist)

Illustration of a website with a checklist being examined through a magnifying glass

Most small business websites don’t fail in an obvious way. The site loads, it looks fine on your laptop, and nobody complains. It just quietly doesn’t bring in many calls or enquiries.

This checklist helps you find out why in about 15 minutes, using your phone and free tools from Google. Tick each item as you go (your ticks are saved in this browser), and you’ll see your score at the end.

What you need: your phone, a computer, and your website address. If you have a Google Business Profile, have its login handy too.

1. First impression on your phone (3 minutes)

Most visitors to a local business website arrive on a phone, so start there. Open your homepage on your phone as if you were a new customer.

  • Within five seconds, it’s clear what you do and where (for example, “Roof repair in Columbia, TN”).
  • There’s an obvious next step near the top, such as a Call or Get a quote button.
  • Your phone number is tappable and starts a call.
  • The text is readable without zooming, and nothing runs off the side of the screen.
  • No pop-up blocks the page before visitors can see what you offer.

2. Speed (2 minutes)

Slow pages lose visitors before they’ve read a word, and speed is one of the signals Google uses to rank pages.

Go to PageSpeed Insights, enter your homepage address and look at the Mobile results.

  • The Performance score is 50 or higher. Google rates 90+ as good, 50–89 as needing improvement and under 50 as poor.
  • The Core Web Vitals assessment says Passed, or the main content (“Largest Contentful Paint”) loads in 2.5 seconds or less.
  • The page doesn’t jump around as it loads (a low Cumulative Layout Shift, 0.1 or under).
  • Images aren’t near the top of PageSpeed’s list of suggestions. Oversized photos are the most common cause of slow pages.

The usual causes of a slow small business site are huge photos, background videos, and too many apps or plugins. They’re often quick to fix.

3. Can Google find you? (3 minutes)

Search Google for these, ideally in a private or incognito window:

  • site:yourdomain.com (with your own address) shows your important pages: homepage, services, about and contact.
  • Your business name brings up your website as the first result.
  • Your main service plus your town (for example, “junk removal Spring Hill TN”) shows your website or your Google Business Profile on the first page.
  • Each page has its own descriptive title in Google’s results, not “Home” or the same title on every page.
  • Your site loads with https:// and a padlock, with no security warnings.
  • Google Search Console is set up for your site. If you’re not sure, it probably isn’t.

If your site doesn’t show up for the service-plus-town search, that’s usually the single biggest opportunity on this list.

4. Local details (2 minutes)

For local businesses, your Google Business Profile often gets more views than your website. Search your business name on Google and Google Maps.

  • Your Google Business Profile appears, with the correct website link, phone number and hours.
  • Your business name, address and phone number are written exactly the same on your website, your Google profile and Facebook.
  • Your primary category describes your main service, not something too general.
  • You have recent reviews, and you’ve replied to them.
  • Your website has a page (or a clear section) for each main service, and mentions the towns you serve.

For the full local picture, see how to rank in Google Maps.

5. Turning visitors into customers (3 minutes)

Getting visitors is only half the job. This part checks whether it’s easy for them to get in touch.

  • Every page has a clear call to action (call, book, get a quote), not just the contact page.
  • You sent yourself a test enquiry through your contact form, and it arrived. This is the most important item on the list: broken forms are more common than you’d think.
  • The form asks only for what you really need. Name, contact details and a message are usually enough.
  • Visitors can see reviews or testimonials without hunting for them.
  • There’s a sense of what to expect: prices or price ranges, how the process works, or how quickly you reply.
  • Your About page shows the real people behind the business. In a world of faceless websites, a photo and a few honest sentences build trust.

6. Tracking (2 minutes)

If you can’t see where your enquiries come from, you can’t tell which marketing is working.

  • Google Analytics 4 is installed. Check with Google’s free Tag Assistant, or look for visits in your GA4 account.
  • Contact form submissions (and ideally phone taps) are tracked as key events (what GA4 calls conversions).
  • If you run Google Ads or Facebook ads, they count those enquiries as conversions too.
  • You have a privacy policy, and a cookie banner if you use tracking cookies.

Many small business websites fail this section, even when they’re spending money on ads. Here’s how to set up conversion tracking.

How did you score?

Tick the boxes above to see your score.

Score What it means
26–30 Your website is in great shape. Focus on getting more people to it with SEO or ads.
18–25 A solid base with a few gaps that are probably costing you enquiries. Fix the unticked items in sections 3 and 5 first.
Under 18 Your website is likely holding your business back. It’s worth a professional review before spending more on advertising.

What to fix first

Not every item matters equally. Work in this order:

  1. Anything that stops people contacting you: a broken form, a phone number that can’t be tapped, no clear next step.
  2. Not showing up on Google for your main service and town.
  3. Speed on mobile, especially a performance score under 50.
  4. Tracking, so you can see what’s working before you spend more.
  5. Everything else.

If your website needs a lot of work, it’s sometimes cheaper to rebuild it than to keep patching it. See how much a small business website costs for the numbers.

Want a second pair of eyes?

I’ll review your website for free: speed, Google visibility, local SEO, how easy it is to contact you, and tracking. You’ll get a short, plain-English report with your top 3 quick wins, things you can fix yourself if you’d like. No obligation and no jargon.

Request your free website review, or see what a full audit and consultation covers.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I audit my website?

Do this quick check every three to six months, and again after any big change such as a redesign, a new service page, or starting to advertise. Test your contact form more often: once a month takes a minute and catches the most expensive problem of all.

What is a good PageSpeed Insights score?

Google rates 90 to 100 as good, 50 to 89 as needing improvement and under 50 as poor. More important than the score is whether your site passes Core Web Vitals and loads its main content within about 2.5 seconds on a phone.

Do I need Google Search Console?

Yes. It’s free, and it’s the only place Google tells you directly which of your pages are in its results, which searches you appear for, and what errors it found. Setting it up takes about ten minutes.

Can I fix these problems myself?

Many of them, yes: updating your Google Business Profile, adding a clear call to action, making your phone number tappable or rewriting a page title are often simple in your website builder. Speed, tracking and technical SEO problems usually take someone who works on websites.

Ready to get more customers?

Tell us about your goals and we’ll show you how to get there.

Get a free consultation